'Market To Everyone...Sell To No One'

Even the big guys get it wrong sometimes.

In today’s hyper-targeted world, trying to appeal to everyone is the fastest way to be ignored by everyone. This marketing mistake—casting the widest net possible—can leave brands sounding generic, irrelevant, and forgettable. The truth? The brands that win are the ones that speak to someone very specifically.

Let’s explore what happens when companies get it right—and what happens when they don’t.

🚫 Failure: Pepsi’s “Live For Now” Kendall Jenner Ad

In 2017, Pepsi released a commercial featuring Kendall Jenner that attempted to align the brand with global social justice movements. The ad was pulled almost immediately after backlash, with critics accusing Pepsi of trivializing serious causes to appeal to a broad, “woke” audience.

What went wrong? Pepsi tried to connect with a universal theme without understanding the nuances of the movements it referenced. By failing to speak authentically to a specific audience, the brand alienated nearly everyone.

✅ Success: Dove’s “Real Beauty” Campaign

In contrast, Dove’s “Real Beauty” campaign is a masterclass in targeted branding. Instead of marketing to all women generically, Dove chose to champion real women, of all body types, shapes, and ethnicities—speaking directly to those tired of unrealistic beauty standards.

The result? Massive engagement, increased brand loyalty, and a billion-dollar spike in value. Dove knew who they were talking to—and did so with precision and authenticity.

🚫 Failure: Gap’s Logo Redesign

In 2010, Gap tried to modernize its logo to appeal to a broader, trendier market. The backlash was immediate. Customers felt the brand was abandoning its classic identity. After just six days of online criticism, Gap scrapped the new logo and returned to its original design.

Lesson? A brand that tries to reinvent itself for everyone risks losing the very people who love it most.

✅ Success: Nike and the Colin Kaepernick Ad

Nike made a bold move by featuring Colin Kaepernick in a 2018 ad with the tagline: “Believe in something. Even if it means sacrificing everything.”

It was polarizing—but that was the point. Nike knew its core audience: young, socially conscious consumers who value authenticity and activism.

Despite some backlash, sales jumped 31%, and Nike deepened its connection with a passionate customer base.

🧠 The Takeaway:

If your message is for everyone, it resonates with no one. Effective marketing starts by knowing exactly who you’re speaking to—and being brave enough to ignore the rest.

So instead of asking, “How can we reach more people?” ask, “Who do we serve best—and how can we show them we see them?”

Contact us...DMs are open.